- 0
- 0
- 0
分享
- 哈罗德·品特《艺术,真相&政治》(2005年12月7日)
-
11-08
近期回看笔记文件整理时候发现,像“匕首一样的反美反战演讲"——Nobel Lecture by Harold Pinter,貌似被平台下架了部分熟肉。这反而是勾起了好奇,借翻译的机会再整理一下该演讲内容。
悲剧是对一个严肃、完整、有一定长度的行动的摹仿,它的媒介是经过“装饰”的语言,以不同的形式分别被用于剧的不同部分,它的摹仿方式是借助人物的行动,而不是叙述,通过引发怜悯和恐惧使这些情感得到疏泄。
——《诗学》
以下为正文部分,
AI译后中文字数约10072字
文章来源:
https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2018/06/pinter-lecture-e-1.pdf
https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/literature/2005/pinter/lecture/
To cite this section
MLA style: Harold Pinter – Nobel Lecture. NobelPrize.org. Nobel Prize Outreach 2026. Sun. 8 Nov 2026. <https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/literature/2005/pinter/lecture/>
© THE NOBEL FOUNDATION 2005
1958年,我写下过这样一段话:
In 1958 I wrote the following:
“真实与虚假之间并不存在截然分明的界限,真理与谬误之间也是如此。一件事未必非真即假;它可以既真又假。”
‘There are no hard distinctions between what is real and what is unreal, nor between what is true and what is false. A thing is not necessarily either true or false; it can be both true and false.’
我相信,这些论断至今依然成立,也依然适用于我们通过艺术探索现实的过程。作为一名作家,我坚持这些观点;但作为一名公民,我却不能如此。作为公民,我必须追问:什么是真实的?什么是虚假的?
I believe that these assertions still make sense and do still apply to the exploration of reality through art. So as a writer I stand by them but as a citizen I cannot. As a citizen I must ask: What is true? What is false?
戏剧中的真理始终难以捉摸。你永远无法真正将它找到,但对真理的追寻却有着令人无法抗拒的驱动力。显然,正是这种追寻推动着整个创作过程。追寻本身就是你的任务。更多时候,你会在黑暗中偶然撞见真理,或者与它不期而遇;又或者只是瞥见某种图像、某种轮廓,似乎与真理相吻合,却往往连你自己都没有意识到,你其实已经触及了它。然而,真正的事实是,在戏剧艺术中,从来不存在某一个等待我们去发现的唯一真理。真理有许多种。它们彼此质疑、相互排斥、相互映照、彼此忽视、相互戏弄,又对彼此视而不见。有时,你觉得自己已经将某个瞬间的真理握在手中,可转眼间,它便从指缝间滑落,消失无踪。
Truth in drama is forever elusive. You never quite find it but the search for it is compulsive. The search is clearly what drives the endeavour. The search is your task. More often than not you stumble upon the truth in the dark, colliding with it or just glimpsing an image or a shape which seems to correspond to the truth, often without realising that you have done so. But the real truth is that there never is any such thing as one truth to be found in dramatic art. There are many. These truths challenge each other, recoil from each other, reflect each other, ignore each other, tease each other, are blind to each other. Sometimes you feel you have the truth of a moment in your hand, then it slips through your fingers and is lost.
人们经常问我,我的戏剧究竟是如何产生的。我无法回答。我也从来无法概括自己的戏剧,除非说:事情就是这样发生的。他们就是这样说的。他们就是这样做的。
I have often been asked how my plays come about. I cannot say. Nor can I ever sum up my plays, except to say that this is what happened. That is what they said. That is what they did.
我的大多数戏剧,都是由一句台词、一个词语或一幅图像引发的。通常,一个给定的词语很快就会带来相应的图像。下面,我举两个例子:两句台词毫无征兆地突然出现在我的脑海中,随后浮现出一个画面,而我也就此进入了创作。
Most of the plays are engendered by a line, a word or an image. The given word is often shortly followed by the image. I shall give two examples of two lines which came right out of the blue into my head, followed by an image, followed by me.
这两部戏剧分别是《归家》(The Homecoming)和《往日》(Old Times)。《归家》的第一句台词是:“你把剪刀弄到哪里去了?”《往日》的第一句台词则只有一个词:“黑暗。”
The plays are The Homecoming and Old Times. The first line of The Homecoming is ‘What have you done with the scissors?’ The first line of Old Times is ‘Dark.’
当时,除此之外,我一无所知。
In each case I had no further information.
在第一个例子中,显然有人正在寻找一把剪刀,并向另一个人追问它的下落。他怀疑对方很可能偷走了剪刀。然而,我不知为何就是知道,被质问的那个人根本不在乎那把剪刀,甚至连提问的人也不放在眼里。
In the first case someone was obviously looking for a pair of scissors and was demanding their whereabouts of someone else he suspected had probably stolen them. But I somehow knew that the person addressed didn’t give a damn about the scissors or about the questioner either, for that matter.
至于“黑暗”,我将它理解为对某个人头发颜色的描述,是一个女人的头发颜色,并且这是对某个问题的回答。在这两个例子中,我都感到自己不得不继续追寻下去。这一过程首先以视觉的方式发生:画面缓慢地淡入,从阴影逐渐过渡到光亮。
‘Dark’ I took to be a description of someone’s hair, the hair of a woman, and was the answer to a question. In each case I found myself compelled to pursue the matter. This happened visually, a very slow fade, through shadow into light.
我创作戏剧时,总是先将人物称作A、B和C。
I always start a play by calling the characters A, B and C.
在后来成为《归家》的那部戏剧中,我看见一个男人走进一间空旷而简陋的房间,向一个年轻男人提出问题。年轻男人坐在一张难看的沙发上,手里拿着一份赛马报纸。我隐约觉得,A是父亲,B是他的儿子,但当时并没有任何证据。不过,这一猜测很快得到了证实。当时的B(后来成为莱尼)对A(后来成为马克斯)说道:“爸爸,你介意我换个话题吗?我想问你点事。我们之前吃的那顿饭,叫什么来着?你管它叫什么?你为什么不买条狗?你做饭简直就是给狗吃的。说真的,你以为自己是在给一群狗做饭呢。”既然B称A为“爸爸”,那么在我看来,他们是父子关系似乎是合理的推断。A显然也是个厨师,而他的厨艺似乎并不怎么受人尊重。这是否意味着家里没有母亲?我不知道。但正如我当时对自己说的那样:我们的开端,永远不知道自己的结局。
In the play that became The Homecoming I saw a man enter a stark room and ask his question of a younger man sitting on an ugly sofa reading a racing paper. I somehow suspected that A was a father and that B was his son, but I had no proof. This was however confirmed a short time later when B (later to become Lenny) says to A (later to become Max), ‘Dad, do you mind if I change the subject? I want to ask you something. The dinner we had before, what was the name of it? What do you call it? Why don’t you buy a dog? You’re a dog cook. Honest. You think you’re cooking for a lot of dogs.’ So since B calls A ‘Dad’ it seemed to me reasonable to assume that they were father and son. A was also clearly the cook and his cooking did not seem to be held in high regard. Did this mean that there was no mother? I didn’t know. But, as I told myself at the time, our beginnings never know our ends.
“黑暗。”一扇大窗户。傍晚的天空。一个男人A(后来成为迪利)和一个女人B(后来成为凯特)坐在那里,手里拿着饮料。“胖的还是瘦的?”男人问道。他们在谈论谁?随后,我看见一个女人C(后来成为安娜)站在窗前。她身处另一种光线之中,背对着他们,头发乌黑。
‘Dark.’ A large window. Evening sky. A man, A (later to become Deeley), and a woman, B (later to become Kate), sitting with drinks. ‘Fat or thin?’ the man asks. Who are they talking about? But I then see, standing at the window, a woman, C (later to become Anna), in another condition of light, her back to them, her hair dark.
创造人物的那个瞬间十分奇妙。在此之前,这些人物根本不存在。接下来发生的一切都是断断续续、充满不确定性的,甚至带有某种幻觉般的色彩,当然,有时它也可能像一场无法阻挡的雪崩般倾泻而下。作者所处的位置十分奇特。从某种意义上说,人物并不欢迎他的到来。他们会反抗作者,很难相处,也无法轻易界定。你当然不能对他们发号施令。在某种程度上,你与他们进行着一场永无止境的游戏:猫捉老鼠、盲人摸象、捉迷藏。但最终你会发现,自己面对的是一群有血有肉的人。他们拥有自己的意志和独立的感知能力,由各种你无法改变、操纵或扭曲的组成部分构成。
It’s a strange moment, the moment of creating characters who up to that moment have had no existence. What follows is fitful, uncertain, even hallucinatory, although sometimes it can be an unstoppable avalanche. The author’s position is an odd one. In a sense he is not welcomed by the characters. The characters resist him, they are not easy to live with, they are impossible to define. You certainly can’t dictate to them. To a certain extent you play a never-ending game with them, cat and mouse, blind man’s buff, hide and seek. But finally you find that you have people of flesh and blood on your hands, people with will and an individual sensibility of their own, made out of component parts you are unable to change, manipulate or distort.
因此,艺术中的语言始终是一种高度暧昧的交流过程。它是一片流沙,一张蹦床,也是一池冰封的水——对于身处其上的作者而言,它随时都可能突然崩裂。
So language in art remains a highly ambiguous transaction, a quicksand, a trampoline, a frozen pool which might give way under you, the author, at any time.
但正如我刚才所说,对真理的追寻永远不能停止。它不能被搁置,也不能被推迟。你必须直面它,就在此时此地。
But as I have said, the search for the truth can never stop. It cannot be adjourned, it cannot be postponed. It has to be faced, right there, on the spot.
政治戏剧则面临着一套截然不同的问题。必须不惜一切代价避免说教。客观性至关重要。必须让人物按照自己的方式呼吸,让他们拥有自己的生存空间。作者不能为了迎合自己的审美趣味、性情或偏见,而将人物限制、束缚起来。他必须做好准备,从不同角度接近人物,以充分而不受拘束的多元视角去审视他们;有时或许可以出其不意地触动他们,但无论如何,都必须赋予他们自由,让他们按照自己的意愿发展。这并不总能奏效。当然,政治讽刺并不遵循上述任何一条原则,事实上,它所做的恰恰相反,而这正是它应有的功能。
Political theatre presents an entirely different set of problems. Sermonising has to be avoided at all cost. Objectivity is essential. The characters must be allowed to breathe their own air. The author cannot confine and constrict them to satisfy his own taste or disposition or prejudice. He must be prepared to approach them from a variety of angles, from a full and uninhibited range of perspectives, take them by surprise, perhaps, occasionally, but nevertheless give them the freedom to go which way they will. This does not always work. And political satire, of course, adheres to none of these precepts, in fact does precisely the opposite, which is its proper function.
在我的戏剧《生日晚会》(The Birthday Party)中,我认为自己让各种可能性在一片浓密的可能性丛林中充分展开,直到最后才将焦点集中于一种压制行为。
In my play The Birthday Party I think I allow a whole range of options to operate in a dense forest of possibility before finally focussing on an act of subjugation.
《山语》(Mountain Language)则不假装拥有这样的展开空间。它始终是残酷的、短促的、丑陋的。不过,剧中的士兵确实从中获得了一些乐趣。人们有时会忘记,施刑者也很容易感到无聊。他们需要一点笑料,来振作自己的精神。当然,巴格达阿布格莱布监狱发生的事件已经证实了这一点。《山语》全剧只有20分钟,但它完全可以一小时接一小时地持续下去,不断重复,没完没了,年复一年,小时接着小时。
Mountain Language pretends to no such range of operation. It remains brutal, short and ugly. But the soldiers in the play do get some fun out of it. One sometimes forgets that torturers become easily bored. They need a bit of a laugh to keep their spirits up. This has been confirmed of course by the events at Abu Ghraib in Baghdad. Mountain Language lasts only 20 minutes, but it could go on for hour after hour, on and on and on, the same pattern repeated over and over again, on and on, hour after hour.
另一方面,在我看来,《归于尘土》(Ashes to Ashes)仿佛发生在水下。一个正在溺水的女人,她的手穿过波浪向上伸展,随后又沉入水中,消失不见。她伸手寻找其他人,却发现无论水面之上还是水面之下,都没有任何人在那里。她看到的只有阴影、倒影,以及漂浮之物。这个女人成为一个迷失的身影,置身于一片正在吞噬她的景观之中。她无法逃脱那种命运,而那种命运原本似乎只属于别人。
Ashes to Ashes, on the other hand, seems to me to be taking place under water. A drowning woman, her hand reaching up through the waves, dropping down out of sight, reaching for others, but finding nobody there, either above or under the water, finding only shadows, reflections, floating; the woman a lost figure in a drowning landscape, a woman unable to escape the doom that seemed to belong only to others.
然而,当他们死去时,她也必须随之死去。
But as they died, she must die too.
政治语言——也就是政治家所使用的语言——不会涉足上述任何领域。因为从我们所能获得的证据来看,大多数政治家关心的并不是真理,而是权力,以及对权力的维系。要维持这种权力,就必须让人们始终处于无知之中,让他们对真相一无所知,甚至连自己生命中的真相也无法了解。因此,环绕在我们周围的是一幅由谎言编织而成的巨大挂毯,而我们就以它为食。
Political language, as used by politicians, does not venture into any of this territory since the majority of politicians, on the evidence available to us, are interested not in truth but in power and in the maintenance of that power. To maintain that power it is essential that people remain in ignorance, that they live in ignorance of the truth, even the truth of their own lives. What surrounds us therefore is a vast tapestry of lies, upon which we feed.
在座的每一个人都知道,美国入侵伊拉克的理由是:萨达姆·侯赛因拥有一批极其危险的大规模杀伤性武器,其中一些武器可以在45分钟内发射,并造成骇人听闻的毁灭性灾难。我们被反复保证,这一说法是真实的。但它并不真实。我们还被告知,伊拉克与基地组织存在联系,并且共同对2001年9月11日发生在纽约的暴行负有责任。我们再次被保证,这是真的。但它并不真实。我们还被告知,伊拉克威胁着整个世界的安全。我们同样被保证,这是真的。但它并不真实。
As every single person here knows, the justification for the invasion of Iraq was that Saddam Hussein possessed a highly dangerous body of weapons of mass destruction, some of which could be fired in 45 minutes, bringing about appalling devastation. We were assured that was true. It was not true. We were told that Iraq had a relationship with Al Quaeda and shared responsibility for the atrocity in New York of September 11th 2001. We were assured that this was true. It was not true. We were told that Iraq threatened the security of the world. We were assured it was true. It was not true.
真相完全是另一回事。真正需要探讨的是:美国如何理解自己在世界上的角色,以及它选择以何种方式来体现这一角色。
The truth is something entirely different. The truth is to do with how the United States understands its role in the world and how it chooses to embody it.
不过,在回到当下之前,我想先回顾一下不久前的历史。我所说的,是第二次世界大战结束以来美国的外交政策。我认为,我们有义务对这一时期进行至少某种程度的审视,哪怕这种审视受到时间限制,也必须有所进行。毕竟,留给我们的时间有限。
But before I come back to the present I would like to look at the recent past, by which I mean United States foreign policy since the end of the Second World War. I believe it is obligatory upon us to subject this period to at least some kind of even limited scrutiny, which is all that time will allow here.
战后时期,苏联及整个东欧发生过什么,所有人都知道:系统性的暴行、大范围的残酷迫害,以及对独立思想的无情压制。这一切都已经得到了充分记录和证实。
Everyone knows what happened in the Soviet Union and throughout Eastern Europe during the post-war period: the systematic brutality, the widespread atrocities, the ruthless suppression of independent thought. All this has been fully documented and verified.
但我的观点是,同一时期美国所犯下的罪行,却仅仅得到了表面上的记载,更谈不上被充分记录、承认,更不用说被真正视为罪行了。我认为,这个问题必须得到正视,因为其中的真相与当今世界的处境有着重大关系。尽管在一定程度上受到苏联存在的制约,但美国在世界各地的行动已经清楚地表明:它认定自己拥有为所欲为的绝对自由。
But my contention here is that the US crimes in the same period have only been superficially recorded, let alone documented, let alone acknowledged, let alone recognised as crimes at all. I believe this must be addressed and that the truth has considerable bearing on where the world stands now. Although constrained, to a certain extent, by the existence of the Soviet Union, the United States’ actions throughout the world made it clear that it had concluded it had carte blanche to do what it liked.
事实上,直接入侵一个主权国家从来不是美国最偏好的方式。总体而言,它更倾向于采取自己所谓的“低烈度冲突”(low intensity conflict)。低烈度冲突意味着,成千上万的人会因此丧生,只不过他们的死亡速度比一颗炸弹瞬间落下时要慢一些。它意味着,你要从一个国家的内部侵蚀它,在它的心脏部位植入恶性肿瘤,然后眼看着坏疽不断蔓延。当民众被彻底制服——或者被活活打死,两者并无区别——而你自己的盟友,即军方和大型企业,已经安然坐稳权力的位置时,你便可以走到摄像机前宣布:民主已经取得胜利。在我所谈及的那些年代,这种做法是美国外交政策中司空见惯的手段。
Direct invasion of a sovereign state has never in fact been America’s favoured method. In the main, it has preferred what it has described as ‘low intensity conflict’. Low intensity conflict means that thousands of people die but slower than if you dropped a bomb on them in one fell swoop. It means that you infect the heart of the country, that you establish a malignant growth and watch the gangrene bloom. When the populace has been subdued – or beaten to death – the same thing – and your own friends, the military and the great corporations, sit comfortably in power, you go before the camera and say that democracy has prevailed. This was a commonplace in US foreign policy in the years to which I refer.
尼加拉瓜的悲剧就是一个极具意义的案例。我选择在这里提出这一案例,因为它有力地体现了美国对自身世界角色的理解,无论是过去还是现在。
The tragedy of Nicaragua was a highly significant case. I choose to offer it here as a potent example of America’s view of its role in the world, both then and now.
20世纪80年代末,我曾出席过伦敦美国大使馆的一次会议。
I was present at a meeting at the US embassy in London in the late 1980s.
当时,美国国会即将决定是否向尼加拉瓜反政府武装“康特拉”(Contras)提供更多资金,以支持他们针对尼加拉瓜政府的军事行动。我是代表尼加拉瓜发言的一个代表团成员。不过,代表团中最重要的人物是一位名叫约翰·梅特卡夫的神父(Father John Metcalf)。美方代表团的负责人是雷蒙德·塞茨(Raymond Seitz)。当时,他是美国驻英大使的第二号人物,后来自己也出任了大使。梅特卡夫神父说道:“先生,我在尼加拉瓜北部负责一个教区。我的教区居民亲手建起了一所学校、一家医疗中心和一座文化中心。我们一直和平地生活着。“几个月前,一支康特拉武装力量袭击了我们的教区。他们摧毁了一切:学校、医疗中心和文化中心。他们强奸了护士和教师,以极其残暴的方式屠杀医生。他们的行为简直如同野兽。“请您要求美国政府撤回对这种令人发指的恐怖主义活动的支持。”
The United States Congress was about to decide whether to give more money to the Contras in their campaign against the state of Nicaragua. I was a member of a delegation speaking on behalf of Nicaragua but the most important member of this delegation was a Father John Metcalf. The leader of the US body was Raymond Seitz (then number two to the ambassador, later ambassador himself). Father Metcalf said: ‘Sir, I am in charge of a parish in the north of Nicaragua. My parishioners built a school, a health centre, a cultural centre. We have lived in peace. A few months ago a Contra force attacked the parish. They destroyed everything: the school, the health centre, the cultural centre. They raped nurses and teachers, slaughtered doctors, in the most brutal manner. They behaved like savages. Please demand that the US government withdraw its support from this shocking terrorist activity.’
雷蒙德·塞茨一直享有很好的声誉,被认为是一位理性、负责且极具外交素养的人。他在外交界受到广泛尊重。他认真听完,停顿片刻,然后以十分庄重的语气说道:“神父,让我告诉您一件事。在战争中,无辜的人总是会遭受苦难。”现场顿时陷入死一般的沉寂。我们注视着他。他没有丝毫退缩。
Raymond Seitz had a very good reputation as a rational, responsible and highly sophisticated man. He was greatly respected in diplomatic circles. He listened, paused and then spoke with some gravity. ‘Father,’ he said, ‘let me tell you something. In war, innocent people always suffer.’ There was a frozen silence. We stared at him. He did not flinch.
无辜的人,的确总是会遭受苦难。
Innocent people, indeed, always suffer.
最后,终于有人说道:“但是,在这个案例中,所谓的‘无辜的人’,恰恰是由贵国政府资助的一场可怕暴行的受害者,而且这只是众多暴行中的一起。“如果国会允许康特拉武装获得更多资金,那么此类暴行还会继续发生。难道不是这样吗?“那么,贵国政府难道不应该为支持针对一个主权国家公民的谋杀和破坏行为承担罪责吗?”
Finally somebody said: ‘But in this case “innocent people” were the victims of a gruesome atrocity subsidised by your government, one among many. If Congress allows the Contras more money further atrocities of this kind will take place. Is this not the case? Is your government not therefore guilty of supporting acts of murder and destruction upon the citizens of a sovereign state?’
塞茨不为所动。他说:“我不同意你们所陈述的事实能够支持你们的这些论断。”
Seitz was imperturbable. ‘I don’t agree that the facts as presented support your assertions,’ he said.
我们离开大使馆时,一位美国助手告诉我,他很喜欢我的戏剧。我没有回答。
As we were leaving the Embassy a US aide told me that he enjoyed my plays. I did not reply.
我还应该提醒大家,当时的美国总统里根曾发表过这样一句话:“康特拉武装在道德上与我们的开国元勋不相上下。”
I should remind you that at the time President Reagan made the following statement: ‘The Contras are the moral equivalent of our Founding Fathers.’
美国曾支持尼加拉瓜残暴的索摩查独裁政权长达40多年。1979年,在桑地诺民族解放阵线的领导下,尼加拉瓜人民推翻了这一政权。这是一场令人惊叹的人民革命。
The United States supported the brutal Somoza dictatorship in Nicaragua for over 40 years. The Nicaraguan people, led by the Sandinistas, overthrew this regime in 1979, a breathtaking popular revolution.
桑地诺人并不完美。他们同样存在相当程度的傲慢,其政治哲学中也包含着不少相互矛盾的因素。但他们是聪明的、理性的、文明的。他们着手建立一个稳定、体面且多元化的社会。他们废除了死刑。他们让数十万长期处于极端贫困中的农民重新获得了生存的希望。超过10万个家庭获得了土地所有权。他们建造了2000所学校。一场规模惊人的扫盲运动,使全国文盲率降低到原来的七分之一以下。他们建立了免费教育制度和免费医疗服务。婴儿死亡率下降了三分之一。小儿麻痹症被彻底消灭。
The Sandinistas weren’t perfect. They possessed their fair share of arrogance and their political philosophy contained a number of contradictory elements. But they were intelligent, rational and civilised. They set out to establish a stable, decent, pluralistic society. The death penalty was abolished. Hundreds of thousands of poverty-stricken peasants were brought back from the dead. Over 100,000 families were given title to land. Two thousand schools were built. A quite remarkable literacy campaign reduced illiteracy in the country to less than one seventh. Free education was established and a free health service. Infant mortality was reduced by a third. Polio was eradicated.
美国却将这些成就谴责为马克思列宁主义的颠覆活动。在美国政府看来,这样的示范具有危险性。如果允许尼加拉瓜建立基本的社会和经济正义准则,如果允许它提高医疗与教育水平,实现社会团结和国家自尊,那么邻国也会提出同样的问题,并采取同样的行动。当然,在当时的萨尔瓦多,反抗现状的力量也正在激烈发展。
The United States denounced these achievements as Marxist/Leninist subversion. In the view of the US government, a dangerous example was being set. If Nicaragua was allowed to establish basic norms of social and economic justice, if it was allowed to raise the standards of health care and education and achieve social unity and national self respect, neighbouring countries would ask the same questions and do the same things. There was of course at the time fierce resistance to the status quo in El Salvador.
我前面谈到了那幅环绕着我们的“谎言织成的挂毯”。里根总统经常将尼加拉瓜描述为一个“极权主义地牢”。媒体普遍接受了这一说法,英国政府也认为这是准确而公正的评价。然而,事实上,在桑地诺政府统治时期,并没有关于死亡小队的记录。没有关于酷刑的记录。没有关于系统性或官方军事暴行的记录。在尼加拉瓜,没有任何神父遭到杀害。事实上,当时政府中就有三位神父:两位耶稣会士和一位玛利诺会传教士。真正的极权主义地牢就在邻国萨尔瓦多和危地马拉。1954年,美国推翻了危地马拉的民选政府。据估计,在此后的历届军事独裁统治下,超过20万人成为受害者。
I spoke earlier about ‘a tapestry of lies’ which surrounds us. President Reagan commonly described Nicaragua as a ‘totalitarian dungeon’. This was taken generally by the media, and certainly by the British government, as accurate and fair comment. But there was in fact no record of death squads under the Sandinista government. There was no record of torture. There was no record of systematic or official military brutality. No priests were ever murdered in Nicaragua. There were in fact three priests in the government, two Jesuits and a Maryknoll missionary. The totalitarian dungeons were actually next door, in El Salvador and Guatemala. The United States had brought down the democratically elected government of Guatemala in 1954 and it is estimated that over 200,000 people had been victims of successive military dictatorships.
1989年,世界上最杰出的六位耶稣会士在萨尔瓦多圣萨尔瓦多市的中美洲大学遭到残忍杀害。凶手来自阿尔卡特尔团的一个营,该部队曾在美国佐治亚州本宁堡接受训练。那位极其勇敢的人——大主教奥斯卡·罗梅罗(Archbishop Romero)——则是在主持弥撒时遭到暗杀的。据估计,共有75000人丧生。他们为什么被杀?因为他们相信,人们能够拥有更好的生活,而且这种生活应当成为现实。仅仅是这种信念,就足以让他们被认定为共产主义者。他们之所以丧生,是因为他们胆敢质疑既有秩序——那个让贫困、疾病、屈辱和压迫成为他们与生俱来命运的、无尽而停滞的社会现实。
Six of the most distinguished Jesuits in the world were viciously murdered at the Central American University in San Salvador in 1989 by a battalion of the Alcatl regiment trained at Fort Benning, Georgia, USA. That extremely brave man Archbishop Romero was assassinated while saying mass. It is estimated that 75,000 people died. Why were they killed? They were killed because they believed a better life was possible and should be achieved. That belief immediately qualified them as communists. They died because they dared to question the status quo, the endless plateau of poverty, disease, degradation and oppression, which had been their birthright.
美国最终推翻了桑地诺政府。这一过程持续了数年,期间遭到了相当程度的抵抗。但持续不断的经济迫害,以及三万人的死亡,最终摧毁了尼加拉瓜人民的精神。他们再次陷入精疲力竭和贫困潦倒的境地。赌场重新回到了这个国家。免费医疗和免费教育不复存在。大企业卷土重来,而且来势汹汹。“民主”取得了胜利。
The United States finally brought down the Sandinista government. It took some years and considerable resistance but relentless economic persecution and 30,000 dead finally undermined the spirit of the Nicaraguan people. They were exhausted and poverty stricken once again. The casinos moved back into the country. Free health and free education were over. Big business returned with a vengeance. ‘Democracy’ had prevailed.
但这种“政策”绝不仅限于中美洲。它在世界各地不断实施,从未停止。而如今,人们仿佛从未经历过这一切。
But this ‘policy’ was by no means restricted to Central America. It was conducted throughout the world. It was never-ending. And it is as if it never happened.
第二次世界大战结束后,美国支持了世界上所有的右翼军事独裁政权,并且在许多情况下,正是美国一手促成了这些政权的建立。我所指的国家包括:印度尼西亚、希腊、乌拉圭、巴西、巴拉圭、海地、土耳其、菲律宾、危地马拉、萨尔瓦多,当然,还有智利。1973年,美国强加给智利的那场灾难,永远无法被抹去,也永远无法得到宽恕。
The United States supported and in many cases engendered every right wing military dictatorship in the world after the end of the Second World War. I refer to Indonesia, Greece, Uruguay, Brazil, Paraguay, Haiti, Turkey, the Philippines, Guatemala, El Salvador, and, of course, Chile. The horror the United States inflicted upon Chile in 1973 can never be purged and can never be forgiven.
这些国家发生了数十万人的死亡。这些事情真的发生过吗?这些死亡是否都应归咎于美国的外交政策?答案是:它们确实发生过,而且确实与美国的外交政策有关。但你却无从知晓。
Hundreds of thousands of deaths took place throughout these countries. Did they take place? And are they in all cases attributable to US foreign policy? The answer is yes they did take place and they are attributable to American foreign policy. But you wouldn’t know it.
它从未发生。什么事情都没有发生。甚至在事情正在发生的时候,它也仿佛并未发生。这一切无关紧要。这一切也毫无意义。美国所犯下的罪行具有系统性、持续性、残酷性,而且毫无悔意,但真正谈论这些罪行的人却寥寥无几。你不得不承认,美国确实有一套。它在全球范围内对权力进行了极其精密的操纵,却始终伪装成普世善良的代表。这是一场精彩绝伦、甚至颇具机智、并且极其成功的催眠表演。
It never happened. Nothing ever happened. Even while it was happening it wasn’t happening. It didn’t matter. It was of no interest. The crimes of the United States have been systematic, constant, vicious, remorseless, but very few people have actually talked about them. You have to hand it to America. It has exercised a quite clinical manipulation of power worldwide while masquerading as a force for universal good. It’s a brilliant, even witty, highly successful act of hypnosis.
我认为,美国无疑是当今世界最精彩的一场大戏。它或许残暴、冷漠、傲慢而无情,但同时也极其聪明。作为一名推销员,它无人能及;而它最畅销的商品,就是自我崇拜。它是个赢家。听听美国历任总统在电视上说出“美国人民”这个词时的样子。例如:“我想对美国人民说,现在是时候祈祷了,是时候捍卫美国人民的权利了。我请求美国人民相信他们的总统,以及他即将代表美国人民采取的行动。”
I put to you that the United States is without doubt the greatest show on the road. Brutal, indifferent, scornful and ruthless it may be but it is also very clever. As a salesman it is out on its own and its most saleable commodity is self love. It’s a winner. Listen to all American presidents on television say the words, ‘the American people’, as in the sentence, ‘I say to the American people it is time to pray and to defend the rights of the American people and I ask the American people to trust their president in the action he is about to take on behalf of the American people.’
这是一种令人眼花缭乱的策略。语言实际上被用来阻止思想的产生。“美国人民”这几个字提供了一种极其舒适、令人沉醉的安全感。你不需要思考。只需舒舒服服地躺在这张软垫上。这张软垫或许正在扼杀你的智力和批判能力,但它确实非常舒服。当然,这一说法并不适用于生活在贫困线以下的4000万美国人,也不适用于被关押在美国境内庞大监狱群中的200万男女囚犯。
It’s a scintillating stratagem. Language is actually employed to keep thought at bay. The words ‘the American people’ provide a truly voluptuous cushion of reassurance. You don’t need to think. Just lie back on the cushion. The cushion may be suffocating your intelligence and your critical faculties but it’s very comfortable. This does not apply of course to the 40 million people living below the poverty line and the 2 million men and women imprisoned in the vast gulag of prisons, which extends across the US.
美国如今甚至不再费心于低烈度冲突。它不再认为自己有必要保持克制,甚至不再需要遮遮掩掩。它毫无顾忌地亮出了自己的底牌。简单地说,它根本不在乎联合国、国际法或批判性的异议,并将这些视为无能为力、无关紧要的东西。它身后还牵着一只不停咩咩叫的小羊羔,像牵着一根绳子一样紧紧跟随——那就是可悲而顺从的英国。
The United States no longer bothers about low intensity conflict. It no longer sees any point in being reticent or even devious. It puts its cards on the table without fear or favour. It quite simply doesn’t give a damn about the United Nations, international law or critical dissent, which it regards as impotent and irrelevant. It also has its own bleating little lamb tagging behind it on a lead, the pathetic and supine Great Britain.
我们的道德感究竟去了哪里?我们曾经拥有过道德感吗?这些词语究竟意味着什么?它们是否指向一个如今已很少被使用的词——良知?这种良知,不仅关乎我们自身的行为,也关乎我们对他人行为所负有的共同责任。这一切都已经消亡了吗?看看关塔那摩湾。数百人未经起诉便被拘押了三年多,既没有法律代理,也没有正当法律程序。从技术意义上说,他们可能会被无限期地关押下去。这一完全非法的机构公然违背《日内瓦公约》,却依然维持运作。所谓的“国际社会”不仅容忍这一切,甚至几乎从未认真思考过这一问题。这种犯罪性的暴行,竟然是由一个自称“自由世界领导者”的国家实施的。我们是否会想到关塔那摩湾里的人们?媒体又是如何报道他们的?他们偶尔会出现一下——成为报纸第六版上一则不起眼的小新闻。他们已经被放逐到一片无人之境,在那里,他们或许永远无法回来。目前,许多人正在绝食抗议,却遭到强制喂食,其中也包括英国居民。这些强制喂食程序没有任何温情可言。没有镇静剂,也没有麻醉剂。只是将一根管子直接插入你的鼻孔,再一路伸进喉咙。你会呕出鲜血。这就是酷刑。那么,英国外交大臣对此说过什么?什么也没有。英国首相对此说过什么?什么也没有。为什么?因为美国已经明确表示:批评我们在关塔那摩湾的行为,就等同于一种不友好的举动。你不是站在我们这一边,就是站在我们的对立面。于是,布莱尔闭上了嘴。
What has happened to our moral sensibility? Did we ever have any? What do these words mean? Do they refer to a term very rarely employed these days – conscience? A conscience to do not only with our own acts but to do with our shared responsibility in the acts of others? Is all this dead? Look at Guantanamo Bay. Hundreds of people detained without charge for over three years, with no legal representation or due process, technically detained forever. This totally illegitimate structure is maintained in defiance of the Geneva Convention. It is not only tolerated but hardly thought about by what’s called the ‘international community’. This criminal outrage is being committed by a country, which declares itself to be ‘the leader of the free world’. Do we think about the inhabitants of Guantanamo Bay? What does the media say about them? They pop up occasionally – a small item on page six. They have been consigned to a no man’s land from which indeed they may never return. At present many are on hunger strike, being force-fed, including British residents. No niceties in these force-feeding procedures. No sedative or anaesthetic. Just a tube stuck up your nose and into your throat. You vomit blood. This is torture. What has the British Foreign Secretary said about this? Nothing. What has the British Prime Minister said about this? Nothing. Why not? Because the United States has said: to criticise our conduct in Guantanamo Bay constitutes an unfriendly act. You’re either with us or against us. So Blair shuts up.
入侵伊拉克是一种强盗行径,是一种赤裸裸的国家恐怖主义行为,它表明了对国际法这一概念的彻底蔑视。这场入侵是一场任意发动的军事行动,其背后是一系列谎言叠加而成的谎言,以及对媒体、进而对公众舆论的大规模操纵。它的真正目的,是巩固美国对中东地区的军事和经济控制。而所谓的“解放”,不过是最后才被拿出来的伪装——此前所有其他辩解都已经无法自圆其说。这是一场对军事力量的强势展示,它导致成千上万无辜者死亡、伤残。
The invasion of Iraq was a bandit act, an act of blatant state terrorism, demonstrating absolute contempt for the concept of international law. The invasion was an arbitrary military action inspired by a series of lies upon lies and gross manipulation of the media and therefore of the public; an act intended to consolidate American military and economic control of the Middle East masquerading – as a last resort – all other justifications having failed to justify themselves – as liberation. A formidable assertion of military force responsible for the death and mutilation of thousands and thousands of innocent people.
我们给伊拉克人民带去了酷刑、集束炸弹、贫铀武器,以及数不胜数的随机杀戮、苦难、屈辱和死亡,却将这一切称为“为中东带来自由与民主”。
We have brought torture, cluster bombs, depleted uranium, innumerable acts of random murder, misery, degradation and death to the Iraqi people and call it ‘bringing freedom and democracy to the Middle East’.
究竟要杀死多少人,才能被称为大规模杀人犯和战争罪犯?十万人?在我看来,这已经绰绰有余了。因此,布什和布莱尔理应被送交国际刑事法院受审。但布什很聪明。他没有批准《国际刑事法院罗马规约》。因此,如果任何美国士兵,或者政客,发现自己站在被告席上,布什已经警告说,他将派遣海军陆战队前去营救。但托尼·布莱尔批准了该法院的相关规约,因此他可以被起诉。如果法院有兴趣,我们可以把他的地址交给他们。伦敦唐宁街10号。
How many people do you have to kill before you qualify to be described as a mass murderer and a war criminal? One hundred thousand? More than enough, I would have thought. Therefore it is just that Bush and Blair be arraigned before the International Criminal Court of Justice. But Bush has been clever. He has not ratified the International Criminal Court of Justice. Therefore if any American soldier or for that matter politician finds himself in the dock Bush has warned that he will send in the marines. But Tony Blair has ratified the Court and is therefore available for prosecution. We can let the Court have his address if they’re interested. It is Number 10, Downing Street, London.
在这个问题上,死亡似乎无关紧要。布什和布莱尔都将死亡放在了极其遥远、无关紧要的位置。在伊拉克反叛武装活动开始之前,至少已有10万名伊拉克人死于美国的炸弹和导弹。这些人无足轻重。他们的死亡仿佛并不存在。他们的死亡是一片空白。甚至连死亡人数都没有被记录下来。美国将军汤米·弗兰克斯曾说过:“我们不统计尸体数量。”
Death in this context is irrelevant. Both Bush and Blair place death well away on the back burner. At least 100,000 Iraqis were killed by American bombs and missiles before the Iraq insurgency began. These people are of no moment. Their deaths don’t exist. They are blank. They are not even recorded as being dead. ‘We don’t do body counts,’ said the American general Tommy Franks.
入侵初期,英国报纸曾在头版刊登过一张照片:托尼·布莱尔亲吻一个伊拉克小男孩的脸颊。照片说明写道:“一个心怀感激的孩子。”几天之后,另一则报道和照片出现在报纸内页,照片中的孩子是另一个四岁男孩,他失去了双臂。他的家人在一次导弹袭击中全部遇难,而他是唯一的幸存者。他问道:“我的胳膊什么时候才能长回来?”这则报道后来被撤下了。毕竟,托尼·布莱尔并没有把他抱在怀里。他也没有抱着任何其他残缺儿童的身体,更没有抱着任何一具血淋淋的尸体。血是肮脏的。当你在电视上发表诚恳的演讲时,血会弄脏你的衬衫和领带。
Early in the invasion there was a photograph published on the front page of British newspapers of Tony Blair kissing the cheek of a little Iraqi boy. ‘A grateful child,’ said the caption. A few days later there was a story and photograph, on an inside page, of another four-year-old boy with no arms. His family had been blown up by a missile. He was the only survivor. ‘When do I get my arms back?’ he asked. The story was dropped. Well, Tony Blair wasn’t holding him in his arms, nor the body of any other mutilated child, nor the body of any bloody corpse. Blood is dirty. It dirties your shirt and tie when you’re making a sincere speech on television.
那2000名阵亡的美国士兵同样令人尴尬。他们被秘密地运往墓地。葬礼低调举行,尽可能避开公众视线。那些伤残者则在病床上逐渐腐烂,有些人将在余生中一直如此。于是,死者与伤残者都在腐烂,只不过身处不同形式的坟墓。
The 2,000 American dead are an embarrassment. They are transported to their graves in the dark. Funerals are unobtrusive, out of harm’s way. The mutilated rot in their beds, some for the rest of their lives. So the dead and the mutilated both rot, in different kinds of graves.
下面,我引用一段巴勃罗·聂鲁达(Pablo Neruda)的诗歌,题为《我来解释几件事》(I'm Explaining a Few Things):
Here is an extract from a poem by Pablo Neruda, ‘I’m Explaining a Few Things’:
有一个早晨,一切都在燃烧,
有一个早晨,
火焰从大地深处
猛然跃起,
吞噬着一个又一个生命。
从那时起,便只有火焰,
从那时起,便只有火药,
从那时起,便只有鲜血。
乘着飞机的强盗和摩尔人,
戴着戒指、带着公爵夫人的强盗,
还有那些一边散播祝福、一边作恶的黑衣修士,
从天空中降临,杀害孩子,
孩子的鲜血流淌在街道上,
毫无声息,
就像孩子的鲜血一样。
连豺狼都会鄙夷的豺狼,
被干枯蓟草咬住又吐出的石头,
连毒蛇都会憎恶的毒蛇。
面对着你们,
我曾亲眼看见西班牙的鲜血
像潮水般高高涌起,
以充满骄傲与刀锋的一道巨浪,
将你们淹没。
叛变的
将军们:
看看我那死去的房屋,
看看破碎的西班牙:
每一座房屋中,
流淌出来的都是燃烧的金属,
而不是鲜花。
从西班牙的每一个枪口中,
西班牙都在涌现。
从每一个死去的孩子身上,
都诞生出一支长着眼睛的步枪;
从每一桩罪行之中,
都诞生出一颗子弹,
它终有一天会找到
你们心中的靶心。
而你们会问:
为什么他的诗歌不再谈论梦想与树叶,
不再谈论他故乡那些伟大的火山?
来吧,看看街道上的鲜血。
来吧,看看
街道上的鲜血。
来吧,看看鲜血
流淌在
街道上!
And one morning all that was burning,
one morning the bonfires
leapt out of the earth
devouring human beings
and from then on fire,
gunpowder from then on,
and from then on blood.
Bandits with planes and Moors,
bandits with finger-rings and duchesses,
bandits with black friars spattering blessings
came through the sky to kill children
and the blood of children ran through the streets
without fuss, like children’s blood.
Jackals that the jackals would despise
stones that the dry thistle would bite on and spit out,
vipers that the vipers would abominate.
Face to face with you I have seen the blood
of Spain tower like a tide
to drown you in one wave
of pride and knives.
Treacherous
generals:
see my dead house,
look at broken Spain:
from every house burning metal flows
instead of flowers
from every socket of Spain
Spain emerges
and from every dead child a rifle with eyes
and from every crime bullets are born
which will one day find
the bull’s eye of your hearts.
And you will ask: why doesn’t his poetry
speak of dreams and leaves
and the great volcanoes of his native land.
Come and see the blood in the streets.
Come and see
the blood in the streets.
Come and see the blood
in the streets!*
节选自《我来解释几件事》,纳撒尼尔·塔恩译,选自《巴勃罗·聂鲁达诗选》,伦敦乔纳森·凯普出版社1970年出版。经兰登书屋集团有限公司许可使用。
* Extract from “I’m Explaining a Few Things” translated by Nathaniel Tarn, from Pablo Neruda: Selected Poems, published by Jonathan Cape, London 1970. Used by permission of The Random House Group Limited.
我必须明确说明,在引用聂鲁达的这首诗时,我绝不是在将共和派西班牙与萨达姆·侯赛因统治下的伊拉克进行比较。我引用聂鲁达,是因为在当代诗歌中,我从未读到过如此强烈、如此直击感官的文字,能够如此有力地描绘对平民的轰炸。
Let me make it quite clear that in quoting from Neruda’s poem I am in no way comparing Republican Spain to Saddam Hussein’s Iraq. I quote Neruda because nowhere in contemporary poetry have I read such a powerful visceral description of the bombing of civilians.
我前面已经说过,美国如今对于亮出自己的底牌已经毫不避讳。事实确实如此。美国官方公开宣称的政策,如今被定义为“全频谱主导”(Full Spectrum Dominance)。这并不是我创造的说法,而是他们自己的用语。“全频谱主导”意味着对陆地、海洋、天空、太空以及所有相关资源的控制。
I have said earlier that the United States is now totally frank about putting its cards on the table. That is the case. Its official declared policy is now defined as ‘full spectrum dominance’. That is not my term, it is theirs. ‘Full spectrum dominance’ means control of land, sea, air and space and all attendant resources.
美国目前在全球132个国家拥有702处军事设施。当然,有一个值得尊敬的例外:瑞典。我们并不完全清楚他们是如何进入这些国家的,但毫无疑问,他们确实在那里。
The United States now occupies 702 military installations throughout the world in 132 countries, with the honourable exception of Sweden, of course. We don’t quite know how they got there but they are there all right.
美国拥有8000枚现役且可投入使用的核弹头。其中2000枚处于高度戒备状态,只需提前15分钟预警便可以发射。美国正在开发新型核武器系统,称为“钻地弹”(Bunker Busters)。一向乐于配合的英国,也打算替换自己的“三叉戟”核导弹系统。我不禁想问:他们究竟打算瞄准谁?本·拉登?你?我?某个普通人?中国?巴黎?谁知道呢?我们唯一知道的是,这种幼稚而疯狂的行径——拥有并威胁使用核武器——正处于当今美国政治哲学的核心位置。我们必须提醒自己,美国始终处于一种永久性的军事动员状态,而且丝毫没有放松这一状态的迹象。
The United States possesses 8,000 active and operational nuclear warheads. Two thousand are on hair trigger alert, ready to be launched with 15 minutes warning. It is developing new systems of nuclear force, known as bunker busters. The British, ever cooperative, are intending to replace their own nuclear missile, Trident. Who, I wonder, are they aiming at? Osama bin Laden? You? Me? Joe Dokes? China? Paris? Who knows? What we do know is that this infantile insanity – the possession and threatened use of nuclear weapons – is at the heart of present American political philosophy. We must remind ourselves that the United States is on a permanent military footing and shows no sign of relaxing it.
美国国内有成千上万,甚至可能数百万的人,显然对本国政府的所作所为感到恶心、羞耻和愤怒。但就目前而言,他们还没有形成一股具有凝聚力的政治力量——至少现在还没有。然而,我们每天都能看到,美国国内不断增长的焦虑、不确定感和恐惧,恐怕不太可能有所减轻。
Many thousands, if not millions, of people in the United States itself are demonstrably sickened, shamed and angered by their government’s actions, but as things stand they are not a coherent political force – yet. But the anxiety, uncertainty and fear which we can see growing daily in the United States is unlikely to diminish.
我知道,布什总统拥有许多极其出色的演讲稿撰写人,但我愿意主动承担这份工作。我建议他在电视上向全国发表下面这段简短讲话。我想象中的他,神情庄重,头发精心梳理,严肃、自信、真诚,时常显露出迷人的一面,偶尔还带着一丝意味深长的微笑。他颇具吸引力,是一个典型的男子汉。
I know that President Bush has many extremely competent speech writers but I would like to volunteer for the job myself. I propose the following short address which he can make on television to the nation. I see him grave, hair carefully combed, serious, winning, sincere, often beguiling, sometimes employing a wry smile, curiously attractive, a man’s man.
上帝是善良的。
上帝是伟大的。
我的上帝是善良的。
本·拉登的上帝是邪恶的。
他的上帝是一个坏上帝。
萨达姆的上帝也是邪恶的,尽管他根本没有上帝。
他是一个野蛮人。
我们不是野蛮人。
我们不会砍下别人的脑袋。
我们相信自由。
上帝也相信自由。
我不是野蛮人。
我是一个热爱自由的民主国家经民主选举产生的领导人。
我们是一个充满仁慈的社会。
我们提供充满仁慈的电刑,也提供充满仁慈的致命注射。
我们是一个伟大的国家。
我不是独裁者。
他才是。
我不是野蛮人。
他才是。
他们全都是。
我拥有道德权威。
你们看见这只拳头了吗?
这就是我的道德权威。
你们可千万别忘了。
‘God is good. God is great. God is good. My God is good. Bin Laden’s God is bad. His is a bad God. Saddam’s God was bad, except he didn’t have one. He was a barbarian. We are not barbarians. We don’t chop people’s heads off. We believe in freedom. So does God. I am not a barbarian. I am the democratically elected leader of a freedom-loving democracy. We are a compassionate society. We give compassionate electrocution and compassionate lethal injection. We are a great nation. I am not a dictator. He is. I am not a barbarian. He is. And he is. They all are. I possess moral authority. You see this fist? This is my moral authority. And don’t you forget it.’
作家的生活是一种极其脆弱、几乎赤裸的活动。我们没有必要为此哭泣。作家做出了自己的选择,也就必须承担这一选择带来的一切。但有一点确实值得指出:你始终暴露在各种风中,其中有些风寒冷刺骨。你独自一人,处境孤立,仿佛站在悬崖边缘。你没有庇护,也没有保护。除非你选择撒谎——如果是那样,你当然已经为自己构筑起了一层保护,而可以说,你也就此成为了一名政治家。
A writer’s life is a highly vulnerable, almost naked activity. We don’t have to weep about that. The writer makes his choice and is stuck with it. But it is true to say that you are open to all the winds, some of them icy indeed. You are out on your own, out on a limb. You find no shelter, no protection – unless you lie – in which case of course you have constructed your own protection and, it could be argued, become a politician.
今晚,我已经多次提到死亡。
现在,我想引用一首自己创作的诗,题为《死亡》(Death)。
I have referred to death quite a few times this evening. I shall now quote a poem of my own called ‘Death’.
死者的尸体是在哪里被发现的?
是谁发现了死者的尸体?
尸体被发现时,已经死了吗?
人们是如何发现这具尸体的?
这具尸体生前是谁?
这具被遗弃的尸体,
曾是谁的父亲、女儿或兄弟,
谁的叔叔、姐妹、母亲或儿子?
尸体被遗弃时,已经死了吗?
这具尸体是被遗弃的吗?
又是谁遗弃了它?
这具尸体是赤裸的,
还是已经穿戴整齐,准备踏上旅程?
是什么让你断定这具尸体已经死亡?
是你宣布它死亡的吗?
你对这具尸体了解多少?
你又是如何知道它已经死亡的?
你清洗过这具尸体吗?
你合上了它的双眼吗?
你埋葬了这具尸体吗?
你任由它被遗弃在那里吗?
你亲吻过这具尸体吗?
Where was the dead body found?
Who found the dead body?
Was the dead body dead when found?
How was the dead body found?
Who was the dead body?
Who was the father or daughter or brother
Or uncle or sister or mother or son
Of the dead and abandoned body?
Was the body dead when abandoned?
Was the body abandoned?
By whom had it been abandoned?
Was the dead body naked or dressed for a journey?
What made you declare the dead body dead?
Did you declare the dead body dead?
How well did you know the dead body?
How did you know the dead body was dead?
Did you wash the dead body
Did you close both its eyes
Did you bury the body
Did you leave it abandoned
Did you kiss the dead body
当我们看向镜子时,总以为眼前呈现的影像是真实准确的。但只要移动一毫米,影像便会发生变化。实际上,我们看到的是一个永无止境的倒影序列。然而,有时候,作家必须打碎这面镜子。因为只有在镜子的另一侧,真相才会直视着我们。
When we look into a mirror we think the image that confronts us is accurate. But move a millimetre and the image changes. We are actually looking at a never-ending range of reflections. But sometimes a writer has to smash the mirror – for it is on the other side of that mirror that the truth stares at us.
我相信,尽管我们面临着巨大的阻力,但作为公民,我们每个人都有一项至关重要的义务:以毫不退缩、坚定不移且充满力量的理性决心,去界定我们自身生活和社会中真正的现实与真相。
I believe that despite the enormous odds which exist, unflinching, unswerving, fierce intellectual determination, as citizens, to define the real truth of our lives and our societies is a crucial obligation which devolves upon us all. It is in fact mandatory.
事实上,这是一项不可推卸的责任。如果这种决心无法融入我们的政治愿景之中,那么,我们便没有任何希望去恢复那种几乎已经失去的东西:人的尊严。
If such a determination is not embodied in our political vision we have no hope of restoring what is so nearly lost to us – the dignity of man.
-
阅读原文
* 文章为作者独立观点,不代表数艺网立场转载须知
- 本内容由数艺网主动采集收录,信息来源为 “树木草皮” 公开网络发布内容。第三方如需转载本内容,必须完整标注原作者信息及 “来源:数艺网”,严禁擅自篡改、删减或未标注来源转载。 并附上本页链接: 若您的内容不希望被数艺网收录,或认为此举侵犯了您的合法权益,敬请通过微信 ID:d-arts-cn 联系数艺网。我们将致以诚挚歉意,并第一时间为您办理下架或删除处理。




